September 26, 2008
Ms. Linda Cvrkel
Branch Chief
United States Securities and Exchange Commission
450 Fifth Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20549
RE: |
Spartan Motors, Inc. |
Dear Ms. Cvrkel:
We have received your letter dated September 8, 2008, regarding our response dated August 4, 2008 (the "Response") to your comments on the Annual Report on Form 10-K for Spartan Motors, Inc. (the "Company"). In light of your most recent comments, we have carefully reviewed our Response. We acknowledge that our Response focused primarily on our goodwill impairment test and analysis under SFAS No. 142. We present the following response to address comments regarding SFAS No. 144 more completely. For the convenience of the Staff, each of the Staff's comments from the letter dated September 8, 2008 is set forth in full (in italics), and the Company's response thereto immediately follows.
Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2007
Item 8. Financial Statements and Supplementary Data, page 22
Note 12. Business Segments, page 37
1. |
We note your response to our prior comment 5, but do not believe you have been fully responsive. Your response only appears to address our concerns related to your goodwill impairment and analysis and vaguely addresses our concerns related to your long-lived assets and intangibles impairment test / requirements per SFAS No. 144. As previously expressed in our prior comment 5, we note from your disclosure that the EV team business segment as of December 31, 2007 has significant segment assets of approximately $54.07 million and has incurred recurring significant segment losses since December 31, 2005. Also, it appears that no impairment charges have been recorded as of December 31, 2007 or for subsequent quarters related to long -lived assets or intangibles, based on the guidance of SFAS No. 144. Additionally, we note that the EV team segment losses continue through your quarter ended June 30, 2008, which based on paragraph 8(e) of SFAS No. 144, could be an example of an event or change in circumstance triggering a test for recoverability of your long-lived assets and intangibles as it relates to the EV team segment. Furthermore, we note from your response to our prior comment 5 that no events or changes in circumstances trigged a test for recoverability of long-lived assets, as described in paragraph 8 of SFAS No. 144, which contradicts the aforementioned. As previously requested, please explain your rationale in not performing a long-lived assets and intangibles impairment analysis for the EV team segment during your fiscal year ended December 31, 2007 and for subsequent quarters, specifically addressing how you overcome the fact that you have incurred recurring significant segment losses since December 31, 2005. Finally, provide us with a detailed breakout by major asset category of each component that comprises the total balance of EV team segment assets as of December 31, 2007 and June 30, 2008. |
|
The EV team reportable segment consists of three operating segments, Crimson Fire, Inc. ("Crimson"), Crimson Fire Aerials, Inc. ("Crimson Aerials") and Road Rescue, Inc. ("Road Rescue"). The breakdown of assets and segment earnings (loss), in thousands of dollars, by each of the operating segments as of December 31, 2007 and June 30, 2008, is as follows: |
|
Year Ended December 31, 2007 |
|||||||||||||
|
|
|
Crimson |
|
Road |
|
EV Team |
|
Consolidated |
|||||
Current assets: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Cash and cash equivalents |
$ |
1,297 |
|
$ |
83 |
|
$ |
1,515 |
|
$ |
2,895 |
|
$ |
13,528 |
Accounts receivable, net |
|
11,043 |
|
|
1,011 |
|
|
3,964 |
|
|
16,018 |
|
|
132,907 |
Inventories |
|
13,888 |
|
|
2,197 |
|
|
6,522 |
|
|
22,607 |
|
|
103,076 |
Other current assets |
|
1,058 |
|
|
1,218 |
|
|
630 |
|
|
2,906 |
|
|
8,902 |
Total current assets |
|
27,286 |
|
|
4,509 |
|
|
12,631 |
|
|
44,426 |
|
|
258,413 |
Property, plant and |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
equipment (PP&E), net |
|
3,083 |
|
|
1,066 |
|
|
3,044 |
|
|
7,193 |
|
|
56,674 |
Goodwill |
|
2,457 |
|
|
-- |
|
|
-- |
|
|
2,457 |
|
|
2,457 |
Other assets |
|
-- |
|
|
-- |
|
|
-- |
|
|
-- |
|
|
1,120 |
Total assets |
$ |
32,826 |
|
$ |
5,575 |
|
$ |
15,675 |
|
$ |
54,076 |
|
$ |
318,664 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
PP&E as a % of consolidated |
|
5.4% |
|
|
1.9% |
|
|
5.4% |
|
|
12.7% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Net earnings (loss) |
$ |
(1,396 |
) |
$ |
(1,387 |
) |
$ |
(2,286 |
) |
$ |
(5,069 |
) |
$ |
24,504 |
|
Six Months Ended June 30, 2008 |
|||||||||||||
|
|
|
Crimson |
|
Road |
|
EV Team |
|
Consolidated |
|||||
Current assets: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Cash and cash equivalents |
$ |
2,342 |
|
$ |
(47 |
) |
$ |
815 |
|
$ |
3,110 |
|
$ |
3,166 |
Accounts receivable, net |
|
9,010 |
|
|
1,497 |
|
|
5,517 |
|
|
16,024 |
|
|
102,641 |
Inventories |
|
13,622 |
|
|
2,942 |
|
|
6,428 |
|
|
22,992 |
|
|
113,107 |
Other current assets |
|
971 |
|
|
980 |
|
|
1,163 |
|
|
3,114 |
|
|
10,977 |
Total current assets |
|
25,945 |
|
|
5,372 |
|
|
13,923 |
|
|
45,240 |
|
|
229,891 |
Property, plant and |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
equipment (PP&E), net |
|
3,259 |
|
|
953 |
|
|
2,886 |
|
|
7,098 |
|
|
62,043 |
Goodwill |
|
2,457 |
|
|
-- |
|
|
-- |
|
|
2,457 |
|
|
2,457 |
Other assets |
|
-- |
|
|
-- |
|
|
-- |
|
|
-- |
|
|
984 |
Total assets |
$ |
31,661 |
|
$ |
6,325 |
|
$ |
16,809 |
|
$ |
54,795 |
|
$ |
295,375 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
PP&E as a % of consolidated |
|
5.3% |
|
|
1.5% |
|
|
4.7% |
|
|
11.4% |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Net earnings (loss) |
$ |
(23 |
) |
$ |
(732 |
) |
$ |
(395 |
) |
$ |
(1,150 |
) |
$ |
25,196 |
|
As SFAS No. 144 states in paragraph 10 "For purposes of recognition and measurement of an impairment loss, a long-lived asset or assets shall be grouped with other assets and liabilities at the lowest level for which identifiable cash flows are largely independent of the cash flows of other assets and liabilities." In the case of the EV Team, the lowest level for which identifiable cash flows exist is at the operating segment level. Therefore, we perform our SFAS No. 144 considerations based upon the three operating segments identified above: Crimson; Crimson Aerials; and Road Rescue. |
|
CRIMSON |
|
|
|
CRIMSON AERIALS |
|
|
|
ROAD RESCUE |
|
is the building owned and utilized by Road Rescue for operations, which has a remaining useful life for book purposes of approximately 14 years. The assumptions used were reasonable and consistent with the assumptions used by Road Rescue for internal budgets and forecasts. To be highly conservative, we reduced the planned revenue forecasts prepared by Road Rescue management for 2009-2011 by 20% in the asset impairment computation. For years 2012 and beyond, annual sales increases were held to a conservative 6%. Based upon the assumptions discussed above, the cumulative undiscounted cash flow value of $14.0 million exceeded the carrying amount of the long-lived assets by $11.1 million. Therefore, it is management's assessment that there was no impairment of long-lived assets at June 30, 2008 based upon the conservative calculations performed. |
|
|
2. |
Alternately, please perform impairment tests for your long-lived assets and intangibles as of December 31, 2007 and June 30, 2008 and provide us with a summary of material relevant facts, assumptions, and estimates you considered in each of the impairment analysis on a individual asset group basis and for those long lived assets, for which no impairment charges were taken, further explain to us why you concluded that no impairment of those long-lived assets or intangibles in the EV team business segment was necessary for the year ended December 31, 2007 and the interim period ended June 30, 2008. We may have further comment after receipt of your response |
|
|
|
Management believes that its year-end and quarter-end considerations of impairment within the EV Team reporting segment (as described above in our response to your comment 1) were appropriate and no further consideration is currently necessary for those periods. However, to be comprehensive, management updated its SFAS No. 144 long-lived asset impairment test of Road Rescue's long-lived assets as of June 30, 2008 in light of the comments received. |
Pursuant to the request included in your letter, the Company hereby acknowledges that:
|
the Company is responsible for the adequacy and accuracy of the disclosure in the filing; |
|
|
|
staff comments or changes to disclosure in response to staff comments do not foreclose the Commission from taking any action with respect to the filing; and |
|
|
|
the Company may not assert staff comments as a defense in any proceeding initiated by the Commission or any person under the federal securities laws of the United States. |
I hope that this response satisfies all of the comments and issues addressed by the Staff. If you have any questions regarding the Company's responses to your comments, please contact me at (517) 543-6400.
Sincerely,
/s/ James W. Knapp
James W. Knapp
Chief Financial Officer
Spartan Motors, Inc.